Lynne Gramling, a businesswoman, does not trust the Democrats who are leading the impeachment inquiry

The television cameras were rolling on the impeachment hearings for the first time this week. It was a big event in Washington but what about in the Trump heartlands?

Many people in the western part of Pennsylvania, a battleground state in the 2020 campaign, were deeply suspicious of the Democratic lawmakers during the first public hearings in the impeachment effort that may remove the US president from office.

These Pennsylvanians strongly defended the president, and their views of Trump and Washington could once again determine the outcome of the election.

Lynn Gramling, a businesswoman, watched the hearing in her living room on Wednesday. When Adam Schiff, the Democratic chairman of the House intelligence committee, spoke, she made a face. “Shifty Schiff”, she said, using the president’s nickname for the lawmaker.

Schiff and the other Democrats were examining Trump’s dealings with the Ukrainian leader during an open hearing in Washington, an historic event that featured senior-level US diplomats. Through the hearing, Schiff and the other Democrats are trying to make a case to the American people that the president has abused his power and should be removed from office.

The Democrats need their support to continue with the impeachment. If they fail to remove the president from office, they will try to vote him out in 2020.

The efforts of Schiff and the other Democratic lawmakers did not go over well with Gramling. Like more than a dozen people in western Pennsylvanian whom I spoke with about the hearing, she expressed admiration for Trump and his term in office and scepticism for Schiff and the way that he handled the hearing.

Pennsylvania is a key state in the 2020 campaign. Trump lost the national vote by two points. But he won the presidency because he had the majority of electoral votes, an accomplishment made possible through his victories in Pennsylvania, Michigan and several other states that are rich in electoral votes.

He will need to win Pennsylvania and a number of these electoral-rich states again to stay in the White House, according to a New York Times study.

Pennsylvania could go either way. People in the western region are likely to vote for Trump. But people in suburbs dislike him. Plus swing voters – people who have not yet decided whom to support – make up about 15% of the electorate, according to surveys.

Political operatives are watching closely to see how Gramling and others in western Pennsylvania react to the impeachment inquiry. The hearings offer a window into their thinking and how things are shaking out in one of the most contested states in the nation.

Gramling’s hometown, Johnstown, was once a workers’ paradise for immigrants from Hungary, Poland and Czechoslovakia. Yet it has suffered the same fate of other US cities that relied on coal and steel. Mills stand empty. Unemployment is nearly double the national average, says George Hayfield, the city manager.

Glosser Brothers, a department store, closed years ago. The place was owned by the family of Stephen Miller, a senior White House advisor, and he spent summers here while growing up.


Media playback is unsupported on your device

Miller came here with Trump for a 2016 rally: “For the rest of your life, you’re going to remember this day,” Trump said. “The change you’ve been waiting for will finally arrive.”

Big change has not come for Johnstown, but Gramling remains hopeful.

She herself has done well in the Trump years. After selling her building-supply business, she moved into a white-brick house and bought “French salon”-style furniture. The living room is decorated with wall-to-wall carpeting, beige paint and a scented candle (“Winter Wonderland”).

Her commitment to the president reflects the lead he commands in this part of Pennsylvania. Here people admire him for his brashness and occasional lack of “couth”, as one small-business owner says.

Says Gramling: “I like that he doesn’t take any guff from anyone.”


Media playback is unsupported on your device

Her feelings about Schiff are just as strong. Sitting on her couch, she scowled at him on her wide-screen TV. He “cross-questions” the diplomats, she says, telling me that he pushes witnesses so their testimony will “suit his agenda”.

With her mistrust of Schiff, she reflects the region’s conservative bent. People here, explains Ray Wrabley, a political-science professor at University of Pittsburgh in Johnstown, see the hearings as an attack on the president, “an effort to undo the previous election”.

The name of the Pennsylvania county, Cambria, where Johnstown is located is Welsh, and people here once supported Democrats: the county voted for Barack Obama in 2008. But after years of neglect, they turned to Republicans. The county went for Trump by a big margin in 2016.

Still some oppose him, and their disenchantment matters: victory in Pennsylvania can be decided by a few thousand people. “It doesn’t take too many votes to swing the state back away from Trump,” says Prof Wrabley.

Outside Gramling’s house snow lay thickly in the grass. It was near-record cold in western Pennsylvania: 13 degrees Fahrenheit (-10C), the same as on this day in 1911. People in nearby Ligonier huddled over mugs of coffee and club sandwiches at a diner in the evening.

David Johnston, a burly man who works for an electrical supplies store, says the hearing was tainted because Democrats called up the witnesses. For that reason, he says, the proceedings were “skewed”, adding: “It’s political in nature more than substantive.”

Johnston’s personal history reflects the region’s demographic changes. His father worked in a steel mill and was a Democrat. Johnston is a Trump supporter and sees Democrats as unscrupulous: “From day one the Democratic establishment has tried to destroy his presidency.”

But some support the Democratic effort. Tammy Fiffick, a Republican, voted for Trump but regrets her decision. An administrative assistant for a synagogue, she is also a billing clerk for lawyers, and she caught up with the hearing while driving to her two jobs.

She says the hearing confirmed what she thought – the president is abusing his power: “They were looking – rightfully so – for something, and this is the one thing they could ding him on.”

But most here still cheer him on, and the impeachment inquiry has not changed their minds.

I left Gramling’s house as the hearing wound down and called out: “Maybe you’ll see something at the end, and you’ll say: ‘Impeach him.'”

She shook her head. “No,” she shouted. “That will never happen.” She shut the door.

The loyalty she feels towards the president is deep and could help him score another victory – regardless of any hearing.


You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • "Budva da bude perspektivnije i bolje društvo"
    on 26/05/2024 at 19:06

    Potpredsjednica Demokrata i druga na izbornoj listi Dragana Kažanegra Stanišić iskoristila je danas svoje biračko pravo u Pržnu, pozivajući građane Budve da učine isto.

  • "OSI onemogućeno samostalno ostvarivanje biračkog prava"
    on 26/05/2024 at 13:53

    Niti jedno od svih 28 posmatranih biračkih mjesta u Budvi nije u potpunosti pristupačno osobama oštećenog vida što znači da na biračkom mjestu nije dostupan šablon za glasanje koji je izrađen u tamnoj boji od čvršćeg, postojanog materijala sa prorezima gdje su brojevi izbornih lista, te da etison trake nijesu pravilno postavljene, saopštio je izvršni direktor NVO Savez slijepih Crne Gore Goran Macanović.

  • "Ne odustajemo od programa Evropa Sad 2"
    on 25/05/2024 at 18:10

    PES sigurno neće povlačiti predloge čiji je idejni tvorac i autor, a neće odustajati ni od ekonomskog programa Evropa Sad 2, koji je osnova za bolji život i ekonomski prosperitet svih naših građana, poručio je poslanik Pokreta Evropa sad (PES) Darko Dragović.

  • PES neće povući iz procedure rezoluciju o Jasenovcu
    on 25/05/2024 at 17:10

    Poslanički klub PES je podržao rezoluciju o Jasenovcu i neće je povlačiti iz skupštinske procedure, kategoričan je generalni sekretar Pokreta Evropa sad Boris Pejović.

  • Reakcija Kneževića očekivana, dogovoriti brzu rekonstrukciju Vlade
    on 25/05/2024 at 15:05

    Odluka Demokratske narodne partije (DNP) o suspenziji dalje podrške Vladi Milojka Spajića do ispunjena njihovih zahtjeva za politikologa Vladmira Pavićevića je očekivana. Kao najbolji način da se izađe iz nastale situacije vidi dogovor i relativno brzu rekonstrukciju Vlade.

  • "Politički odgovorno da DNP i NSD prekinu podršku Vladi"
    on 25/05/2024 at 14:31

    Nakon izglasavanja Rezolucije o Srebrenici postalo je jasno da Pokret Evropa sad (PES) baštini sve političke prioritete Demokratske partije socijalista (DPS) i politički je odgovorno da Demokratska narodna partija (DNP) i Nova srpska demokratija (NSD) prekinu podršku Vladi i da se organizuju vanredni parlamentarni izbori, poručio je lider Pokreta za promjene (PzP) Nebojša Medojević.

  • DNP: Suspenzija podrške Vladi do ispunjenja zahtjeva
    on 25/05/2024 at 11:28

    Predsjedništvo Demokratske narodne partije (DNP) najoštrije je osudilo odluku Vlade Crne Gore da u Generalnoj Skupštini UN–a glasa za Rezoluciju o genocidu u Srebrenici i zato jednoglasno donijelo odluku o suspenziji podrške Vladi Milojka Spajića do ispunjenja zahtjeva a saopštili su i da neće podržati rekonstrukciju Vlade najavljenu za jun mjesec.

  • Nastavak podrške SAD od vitalnog značaja za stabilnost Crne Gore
    on 25/05/2024 at 10:28

    Nastavak podrške SAD od vitalnog značaja za bezbjednost i stabilnost Crne Gore, kazao je ministar pravde Andrej Milović.

  • "Spajić pokazao da će opet prevariti srazmjerne penzionere"
    on 24/05/2024 at 20:41

    Iako je najavio povećanje minimalnih penzija za srazmjerne penzionere, odbijanjem predloga poslanika Građanskog pokreta URA kojim je predviđeno povećanje i srazmjernih penzija na 450 eura, Spajić i njegova Vlada su pokazali da će opet prevariti korisnike srazmjernih penzija, kazao je šef poslaničkog kluba Građanskog pokreta URA Miloš Konatar.

  • "Vlada posvećena izgradnji ekonomskog, društvenog, političkog i kulturnog ambijenta"
    on 24/05/2024 at 20:09

    Vlada Crne Gore posvećena je izgradnji ekonomskog, društvenog, političkog i kulturnog ambijenta koji će omogućiti da se mladi ljudi koji se obrazuju u inostranstvu vrate u Crnu Goru, kako bi u u svojoj zemlji nastavili da rade i stvaraju. To je poručio ministar vanjskih poslova Filip Ivanović na panel diskusiji „Upoznajmo Evropsku uniju iz perspektive Erasmus plus korisnika“.

  • Mujović sjutra u radnoj posjeti Trebinju
    on 26/05/2024 at 20:04

    Ministar energetike i rudarstva Saša Mujović, boraviće sjutra u radnoj posjeti Trebinju, na poziv kolege iz Republike Srpske, Petra Đokića.

  • ASP: Ministarstvo energetike već dvije godine krši zakon
    on 26/05/2024 at 14:25

    Ministarstvo energetike i rudarstva već pune dvije godine krši Zakon o energetici i ne donosi Nacionalni klimatski i energetski plan, kao strateški dokument iz ove oblasti, dok zapisnici sa sjednica radne grupe zadužene za njegovu izradu pokazuju da se budući rad Termoelektrane (TE) Pljevlja prikazuje kao jedno od ključnih pitanja, jer se mora planirati postepeno ukidanje proizvodnje električne energije na ugalj, ocijenili su u NVO Akcija za socijalnu pravdu.

  • Fabrika peleta i briketa - kratko poslovanje, prazni pogoni i oštećeni radnici
    on 26/05/2024 at 09:12

    Vijest da će se u Pljevljima proizvoditi pelet i briketi od uglja optimistično je, prije nešto više od godinu, dočekana u tom gradu. Pogoni su, međutim, radili svega nekoliko mjeseci.

  • U ICT oblasti radi 9,8 miliona stručnjaka širom EU
    on 25/05/2024 at 20:50

    U oblasti informacione i komunikacione tehnologije (ICT) širom Evropske unije u prošloj godini radilo je 9,8 miliona stručnjaka, objavio je Eurostat.

  • Peranović: Ne planira se povećanje opšte stope PDV-a
    on 25/05/2024 at 14:17

    VD direktora Poreske uprave Sava Laketić naglasio je značaj računovodstveno-revizorske profesije u implementaciji poreskih propisa, poručujući da se intezivno radi na reforemi sveobuhvatnog poreskog sistema. On je to kazao na zatvaranju Simpozijuma Računovođa i revizora, koji je minula tri dana održan u Ulcinju.

  • Likvidna aktiva banaka u februaru 1,49 milijardi eura
    on 25/05/2024 at 13:19

    Likvidna aktiva banaka u februaru je iznosila 1,49 milijardi eura, što je 2,69 odsto manje nego u januaru.

  • Kvadrat stana skuplji za 630, plate veće 315 eura
    on 25/05/2024 at 11:13

    Od prvog kvartala 2019. godine do aprila ove godine prosječna tržišna cijena metra kvadratnog stana u novogradnji u Crnoj Gori porasla je za skoro 630 eura, pokazuje zvanična statistika.

  • Spajić: Trajekt Crna Gora – Italija kreće 3. jula
    on 25/05/2024 at 08:47

    Trajekt Crna Gora – Italija kreće 3. jula, najavio je premijer Milojko Spajić.

  • Reformom upisa radnog staža uštedjela bi i država i privreda
    on 25/05/2024 at 08:46

    Privredna komore Crne Gore organizovala je studijsku posjetu institucijama u Srbiji, a cilj posjete bilo je upoznavanje sa reformom upisa radnog staža koja je sprovedena u toj susjednoj državi.

  • Za 11 bivših "dakićevaca" po 2.000 eura
    on 25/05/2024 at 06:32

    Ustavni sud Crne Gore donio je Odluku kojom obavezuje Ministarstvo finansija da bivšim radnicima fabrike "Radoje Dakić" isplati po dvije hiljade eura na ime nematerijalne štete zbog povrede prava iz člana 32. Ustava i člana 6. stav 1. evropske Konvencije. To se navodi u informaciji koju je Vlada usvojila na jučerašnjoj sjednici u vezi izvršenja odluke Ustavnog suda od 24. oktobra 2023. godine.