US President Donald Trump offers a hand to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky during a meeting in New York, 25 September 2019

Image copyright
Getty Images

Did President Donald Trump withhold military aid from ally Ukraine for his own political reasons? That is the big question at the heart of the Democrat-led impeachment inquiry.

Ukraine is not in Nato and it has struggled with years of corruption. But its future direction is of geopolitical importance.

Why does Ukraine matter to US?

For much of its 28-year independent history it has been unclear whether Ukraine would end up aligned with Russia or the West.

In 2014, that uncertainty appeared to come to an end. After a bloody street revolution, Ukraine’s new leaders asserted that the country’s future lay with closer association with Europe and the West. Russia was now seen as the enemy and it responded by seizing Crimea and supporting an armed uprising in eastern Ukraine that has so far cost more than 13,000 lives.

Under the US Obama administration, Ukrainians’ right to decide their own future, and to resist Russian aggression, was defended as an important ideological principle.

That changed when President Trump took office, and Ukraine’s government has not been able to rely on America’s active support in the same way since.

How much military aid does the US give?

The US has a longstanding relationship with the Ukrainian military and has committed about $1.5bn (GBP1.2bn; EUR1.4bn) in aid since 2014.

Much of that has been spent training soldiers and in efforts to modernise the dated way the Ukrainian army is organised and operates.

Image copyright
Getty Images

The latest tranche of assistance, which was held up and then released by the Trump administration, is worth $391m and includes a range of weapons and technical assistance.

How important is US military aid and support to Ukraine?

It is important on both a military and symbolic level.

Where once the Ukrainian military knew that the US had their backs, this can no longer be taken for granted.

The wavering over assistance, and President Trump’s frequent derogatory words about Ukraine, will almost certainly have strengthened Moscow’s hand in peace negotiations.

How is Ukraine linked to Trump impeachment inquiry?

The impeachment inquiry touches on the 2016 US presidential election campaign and also President Trump’s possible opponent in 2020 – Joe Biden. Ukraine is involved in both.

So far no Ukrainian has been called to testify. The inquiry is instead focusing on the official and “irregular” US channels of communication between Washington and Kyiv.

Why does the 2016 election keep coming up?

President Trump’s lukewarm attitude towards Ukraine dates back to the election campaign of 2016.

At the time, Mr Trump’s campaign manager – Paul Manafort – was forced to resign after documents emerged in Ukraine that suggested he had received off-the-books payments from a pro-Russian political party.

President Trump and his supporters say that by releasing the documents, Ukrainian officials unfairly interfered to support his Democrat opponent Hillary Clinton.

Despite the best efforts of President Trump’s lawyer Rudy Giuliani, the evidence to support the claims remains extremely thin. Meanwhile, Mr Manafort has been jailed for financial crimes.

What about the Bidens?

This has turned into the central part of the impeachment inquiry with both parties approaching from a different angle.

It concerns a period in 2014-15 when Vice-President Biden was the Obama administration’s point-man on Ukraine. At the same time his son, Hunter, had a lucrative directorship with a Ukrainian gas company.

image

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Democrats are seeking to prove that President Trump leveraged US military assistance and a White House visit in return for Ukraine’s president launching an investigation into the Bidens.

Republicans are trying to make this about the Bidens. They want to know why Hunter was paid so much, and whether the vice-president used his political clout to help his son’s company.

What is the Ukrainian government saying about it?

Ukraine’s initial response through President Volodymyr Zelensky was to say that he had felt “no pressure” from the White House to launch an investigation into the Bidens. It has become part of President Trump’s mantra when he riffs about his “perfect” 25 July phone call with his Ukrainian counterpart.

Since then, testimony and text messages released by US diplomats have made it clear that Ukrainian officials were confused and worried about the hold-up in US assistance. And that they were being told the way out was to announce investigations into both the 2016 election and the Bidens.

We now know, for example, that the Ukrainians were actively considering capitulating and doing a TV interview that would announce the investigations that President Trump clearly wanted.

image

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Mindful of getting further sucked into partisan US politics the Ukrainian officials involved are declining to give their side of the story.

What do Ukrainians think?

For the most part they’ve moved on. Ukrainians are more preoccupied by their new president’s efforts to bring peace in the east than his phone call with Trump.

President Zelensky has recently made a series of concessions in the hope of getting Russia to the negotiating table. His critics are accusing him of naivety and capitulating to President Vladimir Putin.

0 comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • "Prikupljeni dokazi da stanovi u “Master kvartu i “ničija kuća” imaju istog vlasnika"
    on 26/07/2024 at 19:23

    Specijalno državno tužilaštvo (SDT) i službenici Specijalnog policijskog odjeljenja tokom finansijske istrage prikupili su dokaze koji ukazuju na sumnju da je ova imovina stečena kriminalnom djelatnošću odbjeglog šefa kavačkog klana, Radoja Zvicera, te da ,,ničija kuća" i ova imovina imaju istog vlasnika, kazao je poslanik Demokrata u Skupštini Crne Gore Momčilo Leković.

  • Čarapić: Milatović i njegovi odbornici prihvatili opozionu agendu
    on 26/07/2024 at 17:55

    Kad je bila rekonstrukcija Vlade, jedan opozicioni poslanik je rekao da se sjutra ruši Podgorica i da je to uvertira za vanredne parlamentarne izbore. Rekonstrukcija Vlade je bila pokazna vježba stabilnosti i pokazala je da je vlast na državnom nivou stabilna. Očito da su predsjednik Milatović i njegovi odbornici prihvatili opozicionu agendu koja se odnosi na destabilizaciju i skratili mandat Skupštini Glavnog grada, izjavio je šef poslaničkog kluba Pokreta Evropa sad Vasilije Čarapić.

  • "Nećemo povjerovati etno investicijama Ibrahimovića, neka se pravda do zore za ulazak u vlast"
    on 26/07/2024 at 17:14

    Nećemo povjerovati etno investicijama Ervina Ibrahimovića, pa neka se pravda do zore za svoj ulazak u vlast, saopšteno je iz Izvršnog odbora Partije crnogorskih Muslimana.

  • "SAD će nastaviti da podržavaju reformske procese neophodne za članstvo u EU"
    on 26/07/2024 at 16:40

    Crna Gora ostaje u potpunosti posvećena definisanim vanjskopolitičkim prioritetima, poručio je ministar vanjskih poslova i potpredsjednik Vlade Crne Gore Ervin Ibrahimović na sastanku sa ambasadorkom Sjedinjenih Američkih Država (SAD) Džudi Rajzing Rajnke.

  • "Nervoza PES-a evidentna, strmoglavi pad rejtinga nezaustavljiv"
    on 26/07/2024 at 16:24

    Nervoza Pokreta Evropa sad (PES) više je nego očigledna i uzrokovana je nezaustavljivim padom rejtinga koji je posljedica promašene politike i zasićenosti građana populizmom, obmanama i lažima.

  • "Manjinski narodi u Baru najbolje znaju koliko ste se brinuli o njima"
    on 26/07/2024 at 15:58

    Projekti sa kojima je Bošnjačka stranka ušla u Vladu, a vezani su za Bar upravo su oni čija se realizacija čekala godinama, a pokrenuli su ih ministri i poslanici iz Bošnjačke stranke, saopšteno je Opštinskog odbora Bošnjačke stranke Bar.

  • Pogledajte nova kadrovska rješenja Vlade
    on 26/07/2024 at 15:02

    Vlada je, na danas održanoj sjednici kojom je predsjedavao potpredsjednik Vlade za bezbjednost, unutrašnju politiku, evropske i vanjske poslove Aleksa Bečić razmotrila više kadrovskih pitanja.

  • "Dijaspora veliki potencijal i najsnažnija privredna grana"
    on 26/07/2024 at 14:57

    Vjerujem da je u Crnoj Gori sazrela svijest da sveukupni ekonomski rast nije moguć bez aktiviranja svih potencijala koje naša zemlja ima, saopštio je potpredsjednik Vlade i ministar vanjskih poslova Ervin Ibrahimović. On je učestovao danas na panel diskusiji "Uticaj dijaspore na ekonomski razvoj Crne Gore" održanoj u okviru manifestacije "Dani dijaspori i iseljenika Crne Gore 2024".

  • "Crna Gora i Kina treba da nastave da njeguju tradicionalne veze"
    on 26/07/2024 at 14:30

    Crna Gora i Kina treba da nastave da snaže svoje bilateralne odnose i njeguju tradicionalne veze, poručeno je na sastanku predsjednika Skupštine Crne Gore Andrije Mandića sa zamjenikom ministra međunarodnog odjeljenja Centralnog komiteta Komunističke partije Kine, Čen Žouom.

  • "Crna Gora će imati problema na putu prema članstvu u EU"
    on 26/07/2024 at 14:06

    Poslanik Evropskog parlamenta Tonino Picula komentarisao je situaciju u kojoj crnogorski političari Andrija Mandić, Milan Knežević i Aleksa Bečić nisu poželjni u Hrvatskoj.

  • USSCG: Ne ukidajte doprinose; UPCG: Fond PIO oduvijek bio neodrživ
    on 26/07/2024 at 18:35

    Povećanje minimalne prosječne zarade, smanjenje poreskog opterećenja na rad čini komponentu programa Evropa sad 2, a koristi će imati i zaposleni i poslodavci, poručili su predstavnici Vlade koji su na okruglom stolu, u okviru javne rasprave predstavili Fiskalnu strategiju do 2027.

  • Ulaganja u Željezaru preko 44 miliona eura u narednih šest godina
    on 26/07/2024 at 18:16

    Zaposleni u Željezari vrlo brzo će osjetiti benefite ugovora koji je danas potpisala Elektroprivreda Crne Gore sa švajcarskom kompanijom „8B Capital“, o zakupu proizvodnih pogona nikšićke Željezare, Kovačnice i Čeličane. Siguran sam da ćemo u roku koji je predviđen svjedočiti značajnim poslovnim rezultatima i da će to biti pokretačka snaga za napredak Elektroprivrede i ekonomije naše države, kazao je poslanik Pokreta Evropa sad Uglješa Urošević.

  • Otpis kamate privrednicima koji plate dug
    on 26/07/2024 at 16:20

    Vlada Crne Gore danas je utvrdila Predlog zakona o otpisu kamate na dospjele poreske obaveze.

  • Bivši vlasnici i njihovi nasljednici dolaze do svojih prava
    on 26/07/2024 at 14:14

    Vlada Crne Gore usvojila je Uredbu o utvrđivanju isplate obeštećenja bivšim vlasnicima oduzetih imovinskih prava u novčanim sredstvima za ovu godinu.

  • "Programom Evropa sad 2 postajemo država sa najmanjim troškovima na rad u Evropi"
    on 26/07/2024 at 13:18

    Program Evropa sad 2 je poreska reforma koja podrazumijeva dvije ključne komponente – smanjenje poreskog opterećenja na rad i povećanje minimalne i prosječne zarade u Crnoj Gori, poručila je savjetnica premijera za ekonomsku politiku Milena Milović.

  • Mujović: Biću zadovoljan kada zaposleni u Željezari osjete benefite
    on 26/07/2024 at 11:09

    Odbor direktora Elektroprivrede prihvatio je ponudu švajcarske kompanije 8B kapital za zakup Željezare na 50 godina, a u fabriku bi za pet godina uložili blizu 37 miliona eura. Ugovor je potpisan na sastanku koji je počeo u podne u Nikšiću.

  • Hala u Željezari poslužila kao pretovarna stanica za otpad
    on 26/07/2024 at 09:47

    U hali Željezare je PUP-om predviđena izgradnja Centra za upravljanje otpadom, a zbog sanacije deponije i velikog požara koji je, izvjesno, podmetnut, ista je poslužila kao pretovarna stanica, a otpad se već danas odvozi na deponiju Livade u Podgorici, saopšteno je iz Opštine Nikšić.

  • "Ne koristite položaj za dodatna primanja"
    on 26/07/2024 at 09:39

    Upozoravam sve iz energetskog sektora da ne koriste svoj položaj kako bi sebi obezbijedili mjesečna primanja od nekoliko prosječnih zarada u državi, na račun građana, navodi se u dopisu, koji je ministar energetike Saša Mujović uputio Odborima direktora povodom informacije da pojedini članovi Odbora direktora u privrednim društvima u većinskom vlasništvu države u energetskom sektoru, pored značajnih apanaža koje primaju po osnovu članstva u Odborima direktora, dodatno primaju i naknade u raznim tijelima i komisijama, koje, kako se navodi u dopisu, nijesu zanemarljive, naprotiv.

  • Iz Rajanera tvrde da neće vraćati linije ka Crnoj Gori po sadašnjim cijenama
    on 26/07/2024 at 06:13

    Irski niskotarifni avio-prevoznik Rajaner smatra da aerodromi u Crnoj Gori imaju povećane naknade u poređenju sa drugim evropskim aerodromima, koji, kako kažu, smanjuju naknade kako bi stimulisali oporavak i rast saobraćaja, što je u suprotnosti sa onim što se može vidjeti širom Evrope, Sjeverne Afrike i Bliskog Istoka.

  • Spajić i Vuković u utorak pred Odborom o Evropi sad 2
    on 25/07/2024 at 20:18

    Skupštinski Odbor za ekonomiju, finansije i budžet saslušaće u utorak premijera Milojka Spajića i ministra finansija Novicu Vukovića, u vezi sa programom Evropa sad 2.